On CNN’s State of the Union, Jake Tapper tried to pin down NY Senator Kirsten Gillibrand’s hypocrisy for calling President Trump a racist for immigration policies she used to support. He asked a straightforward question, “Let me ask you if Trump’s immigration positions are racist, were they racist when you held some of those positions as well?” She answered by explaining why she changed her position without answering the question.
Tapper reworded the question and asked it again. “So, what’s the difference, though, just help me understand, between your previous positions, which you characterize as wrong and not empathetic, and President Trump’s positions today that you call racist?” Gillibrand “answered” by launching into an attack on Trump, seemingly saying that when Trump says it, it sounds meaner, and followed with an anti-Trump monolog that distorted the history of the Statue of Liberty and the Emma Lazarus poem, “The New Colossus (Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses…)
And what President Trump is doing is destroying the moral fabric of what this country stands for. We have the Statue of Liberty in our New York Harbor. She stands for a beacon of light and hope for others who need us. Send us your huddled masses yearning to breathe free. We have never been afraid of immigrants. We have never been afraid of refugees and asylum-seekers.
Perhaps Sen. Gillibrand doesn’t realize it’s called the Statue of Liberty, not the Statue of Immigration. The truth is the statue itself has nothing whatever to do with immigration. It was initially conceived by French abolitionist Edouard de Laboulaye, the president of the French Anti-Slavery Society as a celebration of President Abraham Lincoln’s emancipation of the slaves, the end of the Civil War, and the abolition of the institution of slavery. De Laboulaye hired sculptor Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi to begin planning what would become the Statue of Liberty.
Indeed, since it was a celebration of the end of slavery, African Americans have more right to claim the Statue than immigrants do.
Even its official name shows it has nothing to do with immigration. The name “the Statue of Liberty is really a nickname. Its official name is “Liberty Enlightening the World.” Her torch wasn’t there to welcome immigrants, it was supposed to send America’s tradition of personal freedom to the world, to celebrate American republicanism (not the party, the concept), not its immigration policy. There was nothing about welcoming anyone, nothing about borders, or poor people, or bringing any “huddled masses” anywhere. Nor was there anything about allowing people to come into the country illegally.
As for Emma Lazarus’ sonnet, the poem was initially only tangentially connected to the famed Statue of Liberty. Emma Lazarus, who wrote “The New Colossus” in 1883, donated the poem to an auction of art and literary works conducted by the Art Loan Fund Exhibition in Aid of the Bartholdi Pedestal Fund to raise cash for the Statue of Liberty’s pedestal.
Mark Twain submitted an essay to the same fundraiser. It was written with the usual Twain biting with and called “Why a Statue of Liberty When We Have Adam!” which said in part:
What do we care for a statue of liberty when we’ve got the thing itself in its wildest sublimity? What you want of a monument is to keep you in mind of something you haven’t got—something you’ve lost. Very well; we haven’t lost liberty; we’ve lost Adam.
(…)Another thing: What has liberty done for us? Nothing in particular that I know of. What have we done for her? Everything. We’ve given her a home, and a good home, too. . .
After the fundraiser, “The New Colossus” had as much to do with the Statue of Liberty as the Biblical Adam supported by Twain. When “Liberty Enlightening the World.” was dedicated in 1886, the poem wasn’t read. It wasn’t even officially published until 1901 when both The New York Times and the New York World printed the sonnet on their pages.“ Lazarus died a year later of Hodgkin’s Disease, her poem was forgotten.
But in 1903 Lazarus’s friend Georgina Schuyler raised enough money to engrave the verses on a bronze tablet and place it inside the Statue of Liberty base. Mark Twain didn’t die until 1910. If he passed away a decade earlier people might be talking about the Statue of Liberty displacing the biblical Adam.
And apparently, the bronze tablet copy of the “The New Colossus” placed in the base of lady Liberty has a typo. The line “Keep ancient lands, your storied pomp!” is missing a comma. In Lazarus’s manuscript “Keep (,)ancient lands, your storied pomp!”
Below is the transcript of the relevant section of Jake Tapper’s interview with the hypocritical Gillibrand:
Tapper: All right. You have said Trump’s immigration positions are racist. That’s the word you used, racist.
Now, as you know, you were more conservative early on in your career on immigration. CNN’s KFILE is out with a new report this week on your 2008 campaign Web site and a mailer sent from your congressional office back then, a long time ago, but still in your — in your public life.
Take a look. You said you were a — quote — “firm opponent” of government — quote — “amnesty to illegal aliens” — unquote. You said English should be — quote — “the official language of the United States.” You called for expediting the deportation of undocumented immigrants. I know you have very different positions today.
Tapper: But, let me ask you if Trump’s immigration positions are racist, were they racist when you held some of those positions as well?
Gillibrand: They certainly weren’t empathetic, and they weren’t kind, and I did not think about suffering in other people’s lives. And one thing I did 10 years ago, when I became senator and was going to represent 20 million people across our state, I recognized that a lot of places in my state were different, and I needed to understand what those constituents needed too. And so I took the time.
I went down to Brooklyn. I met with Nydia Velazquez, who has been a leader fighting for families for a long time. And I listened. And I realized that things I had said were wrong. I was not caring about others. I was not fighting for other people’s kids, the same way I was fighting for my own. And I was wrong to feel that way.
And so I just said I’m not going to stand by and do nothing for families that are suffering in my state and in my communities.
Tapper: So, what’s the difference, though, just help me understand, between your previous positions, which you characterize as wrong and not empathetic, and President Trump’s positions today that you call racist?
Gillibrand: So, what President Trump is doing is creating fear and division and a darkness across this country that I have never seen before.
One of the reasons I’m running for president, Jake, is because we have to restore that integrity to our presidency, to this country. We have always cared about others. We have always believed in the golden rule.
And what President Trump is doing is destroying the moral fabric of what this country stands for. We have the Statue of Liberty in our New York Harbor. She stands for a beacon of light and hope for others who need us. Send us your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.
We have never been afraid of immigrants. We have never been afraid of refugees and asylum-seekers.
This president has sown fear and division that just makes us weaker. And so I think what he’s done is so horrible and so mean-spirited, that I am nothing like him and never will be because my values haven’t changed.
Here’s video of the exchange:
Cross-posted with The Lid
- A 10 Ft Trump Wall Has Gone Up…in Calais, France
- Fox News’ Bret Baier Shreds Beto O’Rourke For Calling Border Wall ‘Racist’
- Lindsey Graham: Trump not caving on border wall
- Local News Station Shows Walls Work, CNN Dumps Their Story
- Pentagon Preparing to Build Border Wall Should Trump Declare National Emergency
If you haven’t checked out and liked our Facebook page, please go here and do so. You can also follow us on Twitter at @co_firing_line. Please be sure to check out our MeWe page here and check us out at ProAmerica Only here.
Get Your Very Own:
$25.00 You Save 8% ($2.05)
Democrats want you to believe that building the wall is cruel and even racist (of course they think everyone and everything is racist.) Obama and Nancy Pelosi supported the wall 10 years ago. What changed? Are they against it now because President Trump is for it?
Why do they ignore the documented facts and insist that everyone crossing the border illegally has good motives? The answer is simple. Democrats need voters because real Americans won’t give them enough votes to win. We’ve seen them get dead people to vote. We’ve seen them bribe and bus voters into the polls. We’ve seen them get people to vote multiple times. We’ve caught them manufacturing votes out of thin air. Allowing illegals into our country gives them even more votes and will shift the balance of power from conservative Americans to liberal Americans.
It’s not fair to all of those immigrants who have worked and waited to legally enter our country. As conservatives, we welcome legal immigrants to America. Our laws must be obeyed if you want to enter and become a citizen of our great nation. Open borders, however, allows sex traffickers, terrorists, and drug dealers in to threaten the security of our nation.
We must BUILD THE DAMN WALL!
And the best part? This conservative shirt is made in the USA, printed in the USA, on an American-Made t-shirt press!
*** VETERAN OPERATED ***
Sizes: S, M, L, XL, 2XL, 3XL
Available in White
4.2 oz., 100% combed and ringspun cotton, 30 singles
–90/10 combed and ringspun cotton/polyester
–Ash is 99/1 combed and ringspun cotton/polyester
–Alternate Heather CVC colors are 52/48 combed and ringspun cotton/polyester
–Side seams, retail fit
–Shoulder to shoulder taping